Case Study: How to Write a High-Converting Newsletter Signup Page


This newsletter signup page I wrote and designed for multi award-winning social entrepreneur and mentor Nyasha Gwatidzo achieved a whopping 60% conversion rate.

That's 12x the conversion rate of the average landing page.

The goal was not to get as many sign-ups as possible — but instead, to ensure a perfect fit between Nyasha and her list. With the right subscribers, the list would be far more engaged and more receptive to the idea of booking Nyasha for mentoring.

While a conversion rate of 60% is certainly not a typical result, the steps I took to create this high-converting landing page are still a great guide to writing websites that convert well.


REALLY Getting to Know the Ideal Subscriber

A lot of low-converting websites and landing pages are written quickly, in a scattergun approach: the same page is supposed to work for "everybody".

Many entrepreneurs also invite all sorts of people to subscribe to their newsletter... and worry about the content of those emails later.

And I get it — we're all busy and want to get our message out there, fast.

But that approach risks leaving website visitors feeling lukewarm. One-size-fits-all doesn't exist in copywriting.

All my writing follows the Rule of One (not the Sith doctrine — the copywriting rule!). I write each piece for one distinct type of reader, exploring one big idea, making one offer.

With this in mind I decided to start with a thorough understanding of the value Nyasha could add through her emails — and her ideal audience.


Creating the Launch Pad

The Launch Pad is essentially a detailed briefing document that contains every bit of information about my client, their ideal audience and the content they want to share.

For Nyasha's landing page, I compiled it from a range of sources including interviews with former mentees, website and MailChimp analytics, conversations with Nyasha and existing content (Facebook Lives, blog posts and LinkedIn activity).

This allowed me to take a deep dive into who we were going to attract: not just their demographics (global female social entrepreneurs who've been in business for at least 2 years) but also — and most importantly — their psychographics.

From my research, we knew that her ideal audience loved Oprah Winfrey, tried to live mindfully and worked extremely hard to make money for their mission... often while making big personal sacrifices.


Plotting the newsletter

Nyasha Gwatidzo mentors social entrepreneurs.

This means she operates in an increasingly crowded market, which is dominated by coaches and mentors offering their 'blueprints', 'templates' and 'proven 5-step plans'.

In researching her audience, I found a perfect match between their disillusionment with people selling ways to 'make money on autopilot' and Nyasha's unique approach. She doesn't teach a generic course: instead, she engages directly with her mentees in order to help them discover the strategies that best suit them.

Her newsletter was therefore going to show off this special way of working.

We were going to combine mindset work (what gets in the way of following your calling?) with Nyasha's inspirational story (allowing her to generate a cumulative $130 million turnover and over $25 million EBIT since 1987) and practical, easy-to-apply tips to make every day feel that little bit lighter.

With this background, it was much easier to write a landing page that resonated with the right people, and gave them enough details to intrigue them.


Writing the landing page

Often, clients choose to work on the web design first, sometimes even relying on proven templates that later guide the flow of the text.

I prefer a copy-first approach: once we know the conversation that will take place on the page, a skilled web designer or developer can really work their magic to enhance that experience for the user. It's rarely useful to squeeze the messaging into a pre-defined container.


Identifying people's stage of awareness

Matching visitors' stages of awareness is the most important thing to get right on landing pages.

  • Will they be completely unaware of the things a mentor could help them with?

  • Will they be pain aware — knowing they have a problem, but unsure how to solve it?

  • Or will they be aware of the powers of mentorship?

Nyasha was going to use LinkedIn articles to invite people to the landing page, so we knew they'd be aware of who she is and what kinds of problems she can help with. I knew that I'd have to write just enough to explain Nyasha's unique approach.


Writing the headline

The headline had to match people's expectations based on what they had just read about Nyasha.

It also had to get their attention and draw them in:

Here’s why many social enterprises get forever stuck in startup mode

Here’s why many social enterprises get forever stuck in startup mode

Following the principle of 'tell them what you're gonna tell them', this headline gives just enough information to tell people they've come to the right place — while leaving all the juicy bits open... intriguing the reader enough to start reading the rest of the page.


Writing the body of the page

First of all, I wanted to show that Nyasha understands the pain of her reader.

I used the first two paragrahs to draw attention to the dichotomy between the high dreams these hard-working social entrepreneurs set out with and their current reality.

In my interviews, I had learned about some of their specific pain points and the language they used to describe them. Now was the time to mirror that language and use those specifics to show how close Nyasha is to their reality.

This part culminated in the revelation that:

The only thing you’ll ever learn from other people’s ‘blueprints’ is what worked for them (not you)

And an explanation of how Nyasha's approach is different.


Writing the call to action

Since GDPR hit our inboxes earlier this year, we're all a bit less in love with the idea of getting yet another newsletter. So I decided to call these emails a "journey of discovery" rather than a plain old newsletter — highlighting the benefit of engaging with these emails. This wording also conveys a sense of discovery which adds to the appeal of signing up:

Join me on a journey of discovery to find what works for YOU

I then listed all the good stuff Nyasha's newsletter would cover, explained clearly how to sign up, and added information about how their personal details wold be processed.

This allowed me to keep the sign-up form simple and sleek, as readers would have all the information they needed to make an informed decision about signing up:


Designing the landing page

As we had no expert web designer on the project team, I built the page in Nyasha's Leadpages account. Using free stock photos, I drew attention and added a bit of emotional oomph to crucial parts of the page.

It was important to me that readers could scan the page quickly, scroll to the signup field and join the newsletter even if they didn't want to read all the detail.

One way I achieved this was by placing Nyasha's portrait right next to the benefits of signing up. Photos slow visitors down; they're more likely to read text to the left of an image.


The best-performing website I've written so far

Why did this page work so extremely well?

It's the combination of detailed groundwork and a clear user journey:

  • from first hearing about Nyasha…

  • to readers on LinkedIn self-selecting as potential subscribers…

  • to reading an empowering message that resonates.

As a result of this work, Nyasha built a highly engaged list of subscribers, with most emails achieving open rates between 46% and 75%.

If you're looking to boost conversion on your page, or boost your newsletter subscribers' engagement, let's chat!

Whether you'd like me to coach you to optimise your content, or write new content from scratch: I'd love to hear from you.